Word for solution to a problem

I need to find a solution to/for this problem.

Can to and for be used interchangeably here? Is one of them just plain wrong?

RegDwigнt's user avatar

RegDwigнt

96.4k39 gold badges305 silver badges399 bronze badges

asked Mar 2, 2011 at 17:33

mvexel's user avatar

  • I need to find a solution to this problem
  • I need to find a solution for this problem
  • I need to find a remedy for this problem

All three sentences are correct, although the second is less common. Usually, one will find that to is the preposition of choice for the word solution. However, for is preferred in certain cases, and I give two examples to illustrate this:

  • A bunch of students are working on a physics problem set in the common room. C and J are done with questions 1 through 4 and are currently working on 5. A just finished solving question 4 and wants to check her work with C and J: «Hey guys, could you show me your solution for number four? I’m not sure I did it correctly.»

  • Joe had just bought a fridge for a dollar from an old lady down the road. Still unable to believe his luck, he wasted no time in setting it up in the corner of the hovel he shared with his brother, Alex. Only after plugging in the fridge did Joe realize that the door wouldn’t close properly. He repeatedly slammed the door shut only to have it slowly creak open each time to his chagrin. «Hey, bro,» Alex finally said, «calm down. Calm down!» He pulled out a crowbar. «There’s a quick solution for this.»

Community's user avatar

answered Mar 2, 2011 at 23:32

Jimi Oke's user avatar

Jimi OkeJimi Oke

27.1k2 gold badges77 silver badges106 bronze badges

6

I would use ‘to’ exclusively. The problem has a solution, the solution belongs to the problem. I will find a solution to the problem for my boss, because that’s what he pays me to do.

I will agree with both RGB and JasperLoy that if I heard «a solution for the problem» I wouldn’t think it was necessarily incorrect, it just doesn’t sound as good to me.

answered Mar 2, 2011 at 18:05

Hellion's user avatar

HellionHellion

59.1k21 gold badges130 silver badges212 bronze badges

0

As a native English speaker I regard to and for as interchangeable in the sentence you quoted. I would probably use for more often, but I wouldn’t regard to as wrong.

Update: I searched the British National Corpus (BNC) at Brigham Young University (BYU). BYU-BNC found 1165 examples of «solution to» but only 208 examples of «solution for».

Community's user avatar

answered Mar 2, 2011 at 17:37

RedGrittyBrick's user avatar

3

I’m sure you’ve heard people say “Solution For” and “Solution To”, used in different situations. But which one should we choose? And when? What’s the rule?

More specifically, we want to know what is the correct form: to say “Solution For” or “Solution To” a problem? Let’s find out.

In general, both “Solution For” and “Solution To” can be correct. But in this example, specifically, that includes the word “problem” the correct one is “Solution To”. Here, the idea is that the solution belongs to the problem, so we should use “Solution to” a problem, and not “Solution For”.

solution to or for a problem

Let’s see some examples, before digging deeper into the two forms and making sense of them:

  • I’m sure there’s a solution to the problem.
  • Janet couldn’t find the solution to the problem.
  • Is there a solution for Bryan’s problem?

“Solution For” has a less common use. You see it in the third sentence, referring to Brian’s problem, not any general random problem. That is what makes an exception, where the preposition “for” can be correctly used.

However, every time we see a problem being mentioned by itself, “Solution To” is the form we should use to address it.

Solution For a Problem

“Solution For” can be used in some cases, but shouldn’t usually be used to discuss a problem. Every problem has a solution to it, and consequently “to” should be the preposition of choice in those cases. We can find a solution to a problem for someone, for example.

Let’s see what “Solution For” looks like in a sentence:

  1. Does anyone in the class have a solution for number eight?
  2. I need to find a solution to the problem for my boss.
  3. Think about it: there has to be a solution for this.
  4. The solution for Anna is to break up and move on.
  5. We should be searching for a solution to the problem.

There are some cases (not many, actually) where you can use “Solution For”. Usually, it involves a subject (like Anna, in our examples).

Anna’s sentence suggests a solution for her, and not to her, because Anna isn’t the problem – she’s the person with a problem to solve, which is different. In that sentence the solution is for Anna, and although there’s a problem to solve it’s not front and center.

This is clear in sentence number 2, where a solution to a problem must be found for the boss (who’s paying for the solution to the problem to be found, and expected answers).

Another example is “searching for a solution”. In this case, the preposition “for” complements the verb “search” and not the word problem.

For illustration purposes, let’s try to remove “for” from the sentence: “we should be searching a solution to the problem.” It doesn’t work, right? That’s because the verb “search” needs the complement and should appear as “search for”.

Solution To a Problem

Every problem has a solution. We can say that the solution we’re looking for belongs to that particular problem. That’s why “to” should be the preposition of choice when referring to a problem, making “Solution To” the correct form to use in those cases.

Here’s what “solution to a problem” would look like in a sentence:

  1. Theo is trying to find a solution to the house’s plumbing problem.
  2. The solution to the problem is right in front of you!
  3. Please, can you just help him find a solution to the problem?
  4. Charlotte finally found a solution to her problem.
  5. It was up to the school to find a solution to the problem caused by teacher shortage.

In this specific situation, which involves the word “problem”, the only correct way to go about it is to use “Solution To”.

We should think of the solution as an attribute to the problem, like they’re somehow connected. In other words, like one thing is connected to the other, the solution is connected to the problem.

Solution Of a Problem

“Solution of” when connected to the word problem is only correct when used to describe a chemical or mathematical problem. Its use is very specific and not seen as frequently as the other examples we saw.

This is what “solution of a problem” looks like in a sentence:

  1. The solution of the equation was written on the board.
  2. The solution of problems can be fun, if you enjoy Math.
  3. That drink was a simple solution of water and sugar.
  4. The solution of the problem shouldn’t take you more than a few minutes.
  5. We used a weak solution of calcium chloride in water.

“Solution Of” generally refers to a scientific topic, in Mathematics and Chemistry, for example. It indicates an equation, a problem or a liquid used in chemical experiments. It’s a very specific use, certainly infrequent.

Note that even in that sentence that contains the word “problem” it implies specifically to Mathematical problems (and not problems in the broad concept we are discussing here).

Which Is Used the Most?

When talking about a solution, which form is used more frequently? Let’s look at the graph from Google Ngram Viewer below.

solution to the problem,solution for the problem,solution of the problem

According to the graph, “Solution For the Problem” is the least used. It makes sense to us, since in most cases it’d be an incorrect form, that should be avoided

“Solution of the problem” was used more often in the past, but we see the decline in its usage since particularly since the 1960’s.

“Solution to the problem” appears more often and we believe it’s because it’s the most correct form, which people choose more often in their daily lives.

Final Thoughts

When discussing a problem, should we use “Solution For”, “Solution To”, or “Solution Of”? “Solution Of” should exclusively be used for scientific sentences. “Solution For” is correct in a few cases, but not when the word “problem” is present. “Solution To a Problem” is the correct form to use.

martin lassen dam grammarhow

Martin holds a Master’s degree in Finance and International Business. He has six years of experience in professional communication with clients, executives, and colleagues. Furthermore, he has teaching experience from Aarhus University. Martin has been featured as an expert in communication and teaching on Forbes and Shopify. Read more about Martin here.

  • #1

Hello…

Is it correct to say: «i have a solution to that problem»? or is correct with «for»?

I think «to» is correct, but I’m not sure.. Can you help me??

Thanks

  • timpeac


    • #2

    «To» is fine. «For» is possible, but not quite so usual, I’d say.

    • #3

    Thanks!! :)

    • #4

    Hi there everyone! My question is: There is a solution to or for your problem? Are both right?

    Thanks in advance.

    audiolaik


    • #5

    Hi there everyone! My question is: There is a solution to or for your problem? Are both right?

    Thanks in advance.

    Hello,

    I would vote for to.

    Loob


    • #6

    I would also, like audio, vote for «to»:)

    • #7

    Hello, I’d like to know which of the following sentences is correct:

    -«We have the solution to all your gifts»
    -«We have the solution for all your gifts»

    I don’t really know the difference between «solution to» and «solution for» so it’d be great if someone could help me. Thanks in advance :)

    chasfh


    • #8

    Technically, neither. A gift is not something that begs a solution.

    However, problems beg solutions, so the one to use is:

    We have the solution to all your problems.

    You can use «solutions for» when speaking of the recipient of the solution, as opposed to linking a solution to a problem:

    We have solutions for your family in your time of need.

    • #9

    Neither one is correct. The second sentence is almost right. Try this — «We have the solution for all

    of

    your gift needs». If you wrote «We have the solution for all

    of

    your gifts», you are implying that your gifts have problems that require solutions.

    panjandrum


    • #10

    << Moderator note.
    Please remember to look for the answer in the forum before posting a question.
    Today’s question has been added to previous threads — easily found by using the dictionary and thread title search for solution for to. >>

    timpeac


    • #11

    Neither one is correct. The second sentence is almost right. Try this — «We have the solution for all

    of

    your gift needs». If you wrote «We have the solution for all

    of

    your gifts», you are implying that your gifts have problems that require solutions.

    Yes — «gift needs», exactly what I was going to suggest.

    • #12

    Can I say to their problem or for their problem?

    People often see cosmetic surgery as a solution to their problem of been unsatisfied with their look.

    SwissPete


    • #13

    In English, the expression is normally «the solution to a problem».

    PS: You mean being, not been, right?

    timpeac


    • #14

    << Moderator note.
    Please remember to look for the answer in the forum before posting a question.
    Today’s question has been added to previous threads — easily found by using the dictionary and thread title search for solution for to. >>

    • #15

    Hi,

    I have a solution to that problem.
    I have a remedy for that problem.

    It is interesting that we probably say «solution to«, but «remedy for«, although the meanings is similar.
    I feel like understanding it. What do you feel when you say that? Why do you possibly feel uneasy with these collocations: «solution for» and «remedy to«?

    • #16

    I don’t think there’s anything inherent in the words «to» or «for» that makes either one of them more appropriate in a given context, Tommy. The sad truth is that these little words are just used so much over time that a very weighty precedent is established, according to which a speaker would more probably choose one over another in a different context.

    You can see this working very interestingly in some of the answers given on this thread. To whit, look at the sentences that follow these forms:

    He came up with a very ingenious solution to the problem.
    We offer a range of solutions for all of your home-remodeling problems!
    (BUT: The philosopher offered ingenious solutions to the three problems first posed by Leibniz.)

    My sense is that when «problems» are counted as a non-finite set, «for» collocates better. (Or is it that when the problem is seen as more open-ended «for» is preferred?) But it’s also true that in advertising «for» is more common, probably for no reason except tradition. Prepositions in all languages are entirely arbitrary, after a certain point, and the only way to learn how to use them is by amassing a large familiarity with the language as it is used.

    PaulQ


    • #17

    Over the years, remedy … [n./np] has been followed by of, against, for and to.

    Of is obsolete, a1387 J. Trevisa tr. R. Higden Polychron. (St. John’s Cambr.) (1872) IV. 11 Alisaundre..axede a tool to slee hymself in remedie of sorwe [L. in remedium doloris].
    against is archaic, 1837 C. R. Goring & A. Pritchard Microgr. 168 In this respect..we have a remedy against those optical deceptions.
    for is usual a1862 H. T. Buckle Hist. Civilisation Eng. (1873) II. viii. 582 The only remedy for superstition is knowledge.
    and…

    Remedy to is OK in the right context:
    OED: 1985 A. Downs in P. E. Peterson New Urban Reality iii. 287 What remedies to these rather staggering problems have been proposed by the authors of the essays in this volume?

    For is most popular as it is instrumental and intended-possessive «The remedy for your problem is posting on WRF.»

    The solution to is most popular as it has the idea of going towards a resolution of a problem, although the for version (for the reasons above) is also used.

    As always, much is dependent upon context.:)

    • #18

    lucas-sp, PaulQ, great, thank you!

    Over the years, remedy … [n./np] has been followed by of, against, for and to.

    Of is obsolete, a1387 J. Trevisa tr. R. Higden Polychron. (St. John’s Cambr.) (1872) IV. 11 Alisaundre..axede a tool to slee hymself in remedie of sorwe [L. in remedium doloris].
    against is archaic, 1837 C. R. Goring & A. Pritchard Microgr. 168 In this respect..we have a remedy against those optical deceptions.
    for is usual a1862 H. T. Buckle Hist. Civilisation Eng. (1873) II. viii. 582 The only remedy for superstition is knowledge.
    and…

    Remedy to is OK in the right context:
    OED: 1985 A. Downs in P. E. Peterson New Urban Reality iii. 287 What remedies to these rather staggering problems have been proposed by the authors of the essays in this volume?

    Could you please share your sources, e.g. internet links?

    • #19

    I think all of Paul’s citations are from the OED.

    PaulQ


    • #20

    Indeed. Thanks lucas. I spent time formatting and not giving my sources.

    taraa


    • #21

    Indeed. Thanks lucas. I spent time formatting and not giving my sources.

    Can we use «for» after «solution», please?
    «However, let it be clear that peer-to-peer technology can at best be only a partial solution to solving administrative scalability. Eventually, it will have to be dealt with.»

    Difference Between Solution to and Solution for

    Hello English learners!

    This post is going to discuss the difference between solution to and solution for

    Once again, the difference in the phrase is centered around the prepositions.

    If we understand the preposition behind the word we can unlock the mystery behind the phrase.

    Let’s focus on the prepositions!

    I often need to explain the word to to my students.

    If you can remember that the word to means movement, then you will be able to use this confusing preposition correctly.

    Here are some examples:

    • I am going to the store. (Go will always have to after it) There is movement in this sentence so we need to use the word to.
    • I talked to your mother yesterday. (The words that I said, moved from my mouth to someone else’s ears).
    • We drove to the beach on the weekend. (Physical movement is happening in this sentence)
    • She listened to the advice that her friend gave her. (The words are moving from one person to another)

    Now let’s look at the preposition for.

    A quick and easy way to know when to use for is to think about presents.

    If you are giving a type of present to someone then use the preposition for.

    We can also think of this as transfer of an object. An object moves from one person to another and if you are the person transferring this object then use for.

    Here are some examples to help clear up this concept:

    • I have a gift for you. (You are giving a present to someone)
    • Students, I have a homework assignment for you. (I know, this is not really a present, but a type of gift is being given to the students. Gifts can be bad, like homework and fruitcake)
    • Mary has some information for you. (There is some information being passed from one person to another)

    Now, let’s look at the difference between solution to and solution for.

    In English, we generally say solution to a problem.

    Going back to our definition of giving a present or a gift when using for, it doesn’t make sense to give a gift to a problem since a problem is not a living thing.

    For example,

    • After hours of working, she found the solution to the math problem. 
    • The mechanic found a solution to the car’s over-heating issue.

    When a solution is found for an organism we use solution for.

    For example,

    • They found a solution for their neighbors. 
    • The doctor found a solution for the patient.

    If you consider the thing to be a living organism like in some cases a company or a city you can use solution for.

    For example,

    • The new accountant found a solution to the company’s financial problem.
    • The city contracted new engineers to find a solution for the traffic problem in the city. (Here we treat the traffic like a moving and living organism)

    In conclusion, if the object is static and does not move or you not consider it to be a living organism then use solution to, otherwise use solution for.

    Comment in the box below. Did this post help you?

    How many sentences can you come up with using solution to and solution for?

    Check out other helpful posts on our blog www.myenglishteacher.eu/blog !


    More for you:
    What is the difference between obviously and absolutely …
    Difference between Since and For 

    *

    Словосочетания

    Автоматический перевод

    решение проблемы

    Перевод по словам

    solution  — решение, раствор, разрешение, растворение, отгадка, объяснение, распускание
    problem  — проблема, задача, вопрос, проблемный

    Примеры

    There is no obvious solution to the problem.

    Очевидного решения этой проблемы не существует.

    She suggested a partial solution to the problem.

    Она предложила частичное решение этой задачи.

    The solution to the problem was relatively simple.

    Решение задачи было относительно простым.

    He found an uncomplicated solution to the problem.

    Он нашёл несложное решение данной задачи.

    They came up with a better solution to the problem.

    Они придумали лучшее решение этой проблемы.

    They masterminded a unique solution to the problem.

    Они разработали уникальное решение этой проблемы.

    In the end we found a very neat solution to the problem.

    В конце концов мы нашли очень изящное решение этой проблемы.

    ещё 15 примеров свернуть

    Примеры, ожидающие перевода

    …a temporary suspension of the gas tax was just a crowd-pleasing juggle that was not a long-term solution to the energy problem…  

    Для того чтобы добавить вариант перевода, кликните по иконке , напротив примера.

    Понравилась статья? Поделить с друзьями:
  • Word for smart girl
  • Word for soft smile
  • Word for small snacks
  • Word for social problems
  • Word for small in comparison