Is there a term for the phenomenon when you can replace one word in a sentence with a typically opposing meaning word and maintain the meaning of the sentence?
Examples:
I’m down for that!
I’m up for that!
or
Slim chance.
Fat chance.
Admittedly, «fat chance» probably originated as a sarcastic derivation of «slim chance», but in practice, they convey the same thing.
This is slightly related to this question, but that one’s asking about a specific case (which may or may not fall into the phenomenon I’m asking about). I’m just looking to see if there is an established term I can use to search for more examples.
asked Jan 29, 2014 at 4:13
trejajotrejajo
3072 gold badges3 silver badges12 bronze badges
11
Words that have opposite meanings depending on context are called contranyms; Janus words, from the Roman god of doors between beginnings and ends. It’s not exactly what you’re looking for, but the term might get you on the right path.
But I’d guess most examples include neologisms — new colloquialisms we may use but might not be widely «accepted» yet, like «sick» meaning an awesome new DLC for a staid game, where the word («sick») also retains it’s everyday meaning of «not well». The neologism («sick» with a positive connotation) is then combined with an antonym for the original word’s meaning (antonym of «sick», like «healthy»), to produce the effect the OP is asking for: neologism[word] + antonym[word].
answered Feb 8, 2014 at 13:37
3
Great question! I was looking through the list of *nym words trying to find one that might fit. I don’t know of an existing word for this, but when I started thinking about it, I realized that it is a special type of synonym (because it’s a word or phrase that means the same thing as another). But it’s special because the phrases have antonyms within them. So if I had to make up a word for this, I’d probably call it:
synantonymonym
It’s an antonym within a synonym! But since saying «an antonym within a synonym» is not a single word, I’d say synantonymonym (syn — ant — o — nym — o — nym). Pronounced: sɪn ænt ə nɪm ə nɪm.
What do you think, does this work?
answered Jan 30, 2014 at 20:56
2
A synonym is a word having the same or nearly the same meaning as another word in certain contexts. The adjective form is synonymous. Synonymy is the relationship that exists between words with closely related meanings. The word comes from the Greek meaning «same name.» Contrast with an antonym. A synonym for the term synonym is poecilonym.
Key Takeaways
- English has gathered many words from different languages, leading to synonyms.
- There is academic debate about whether two different words can truly be the same.
- Near-synonyms are very close in meaning.
Synonyms occur in a language in different contexts, such as formal and informal language, like you’d use in conversation vs. a business or academic paper. Also, some synonyms have slightly different connotations when they’re used, even though they might mean the same thing. For example, look at the differences between the terms for money: moolah, greenbacks, cash, currency, and revenues, which all occur in different contexts and levels of formality. Synonyms may also be nested inside one another, which is referred to as a kangaroo word.
Also, English has inherited and borrowed many words from other languages and kept some duplicates. (It’s also why some words have sound alike or don’t spell out as they sound, but those are additional topics.)
Synonyms saw a rise in the English language during the Norman conquest when the ruling class spoke Norman French and the lower classes continued to speak Old English. As a result, the Norman-originated word people exists alongside the Saxon-derived folk.
«The consequence of extensive borrowing from French, Latin, and Greek throughout the history of English is the creation of groups of synonyms occupying different registers (contexts within which they may be used): freedom and liberty; happiness and felicity; depth and profundity.»
— author Simon Horobin
«Insights into the relationships between such synonyms can be gleaned by comparing their uses in forming new words. The Old English word bird gives us a term of abuse, birdbrain, Latin avis is the source of more technical words such as aviation and aviary, while Greek ornith is the root of exclusively scientific formations, such as ornithology.»
— «How English Became English.» Oxford University Press, 2016
Can Two Words Be Truly Synonymous?
There is some debate as to whether two words can truly be synonymous. If they’re different words, they must mean something slightly different or have contexts where you’d use one or the other, the reasoning goes, which makes them only nearly synonymous but not truly the same thing.
Two words just can’t be completely interchangeable in all occurrences. When would two words have all of exactly the same meanings?
«The search for synonyms is a well-established classroom exercise, but it is as well to remember that lexemes rarely (if ever) have exactly the same meaning. … There are usually stylistic, regional, emotional, or other differences to consider. … Two lexemes might be synonymous in one sentence but different in another: range and selection are synonyms in What a nice __ of furnishings, but not in There’s the mountain __.
— David Crystal in «How Language Works.» Overlook, 2006
When a language does have two different words that mean the exact same thing, oftentimes one will stop being used, as it’s unnecessary, or it will take on a different meaning over time. And two synonyms used in different contexts, by definition, can’t be exactly the same.
At best, the theory relates, that the closest absolute synonymity can get is a technical word for something and a common name used in conversation for the same thing or dialect differences, such as between British English and American English (lorry vs. truck, boot vs. trunk.)
However, if we look at the definition of synonymous, that is, words meaning nearly the same thing rather than exactly the same thing in every situation, the theory that synonymity is impossible might just not hold up.
This aspect of English—having words that have different meanings in different contexts, as well as having doublets and triplets—is also a result of the language having inherited and borrowed so many words from different languages.
The doublets frail and fragile came to English from the same Latin root fragilis, but one came from French and one from Latin directly. The triplets real, royal, and regal came from Anglo-Norman, French, and Latin, notes Britannica.
Near-Synonyms
Near-synonyms would be just that—words that are closely related as to just about be interchangeable but have different connotations, attitudes, or implications that you’d want to be aware of, making one word more appropriate for a context than another. Anything you can find in a thesaurus has a list of near-synonyms galore. For example, lie finds falsehood, fib, misrepresentation, and untruth, each with different nuances and shades of meaning that each can give to the context it’s used in.
It can be tricky when translating between languages, as you need to know the implications and connotations for the word in the original language and make sure you pick up those nuances in the destination language.
The Lighter Side of Synonyms
Paul Dickson’s book «Intoxerated» claims, «The English language includes more synonyms for ‘drunk’ than for any other word.» Here are just a few of the 2,964 synonyms for drunk in his book:
- Blind
- Blitzed
- Blotto
- Bombed
- Buzzed
- Hammered
- High
- Inebriated
- Loaded
- Looped
- Merry
- Messed up
- Off the wagon
- Pickled
- Pifflicated
- Plastered
- Ripped
- Sloshed
- Smashed
- Snockered
- Soused
- Stewed
- Three sheets to the wind
- Tight
- Tipsy
- Trashed
- Wasted
- Wrecked
—»Intoxerated: The Definitive Drinker’s Dictionary.» Melville House, 2012
-
1
the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > the same thing
-
2
the same thing, (be) one and the same
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > the same thing, (be) one and the same
-
3
the same thing, one and the same
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > the same thing, one and the same
-
4
the same thing applies to the theory of …
• то же применимо к теории…
English-Russian dictionary of phrases and cliches for a specialist researcher > the same thing applies to the theory of …
-
5
the same thing recurred again with great and astonishing frequence
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > the same thing recurred again with great and astonishing frequence
-
6
the same thing recurred again with great and astonishing frequency
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > the same thing recurred again with great and astonishing frequency
-
7
amount to the same thing
быть одинаковым, иметь тот же эффект
You can either take a taxi or go by bus; it will amount to the same thing.
English-Russian small dictionary of idioms > amount to the same thing
-
8
it amounts to the same thing
разг.
это одно и то же, никакой разницы нет
You could go by bus or by tram. It comes to the same thing. — Можете ехать автобусом или трамваем. Это все равно.
Large English-Russian phrasebook > it amounts to the same thing
-
9
come to the same thing
oзнaчaть тo жe caмoe, быть paвнocильным чeму-л.
‘Why ‘to die’?’ ‘Because if the Governor doesn’t succeed in getting me shot, I shall be sent to the galleys and for me that comes to the same thing. I have not got the health to live through it’ (E. Voynich)
Concise English-Russian phrasebook > come to the same thing
-
10
I am tired of doing the same thing all the time
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > I am tired of doing the same thing all the time
-
11
Both formulas amount to the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > Both formulas amount to the same thing
-
12
achieve the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > achieve the same thing
-
13
he said the same thing over and over (again)
Общая лексика:он все время повторял одно и то же
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > he said the same thing over and over (again)
-
14
he said the same thing over and over again
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > he said the same thing over and over again
-
15
it all amounts to the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it all amounts to the same thing
-
16
it all comes to the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it all comes to the same thing
-
17
it amounts to the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it amounts to the same thing
-
18
it comes to the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it comes to the same thing
-
19
it is the same thing
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it is the same thing
-
20
it is the same thing or near so
Универсальный англо-русский словарь > it is the same thing or near so
Страницы
- Следующая →
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
См. также в других словарях:
-
the same thing — used to say that two things are alike or have the same meaning Lying and cheating amount to much the same thing. • • • Main Entry: ↑same … Useful english dictionary
-
(The Same Thing Happens with) The Birds and the Bees — is a popular song, written by Harry Warren and Mack David and published in 1956. It was written for the musical film, The Birds and the Bees (where it was performed by George Gobel and Mitzi Gaynor) and has been recorded by a number of singers,… … Wikipedia
-
(We Want) the Same Thing — Infobox Single Name = (We Want) the Same Thing Artist = Belinda Carlisle from Album = Runaway Horses B side = Released = October 2, 1990 (UK) Format = CD Recorded = Genre = Pop Length = 4:16 Label = Virgin Writer = Rick Nowels, Ellen Shipley… … Wikipedia
-
amount to the same thing — amount/come/to the same thing phrase to have the same meaning or effect as something else Whether someone made a mistake or whether there’s a fault in the system, it all comes to the same thing – sheer inefficiency. Thesaurus: to be similar to,… … Useful english dictionary
-
come to the same thing — amount/come/to the same thing phrase to have the same meaning or effect as something else Whether someone made a mistake or whether there’s a fault in the system, it all comes to the same thing – sheer inefficiency. Thesaurus: to be similar to,… … Useful english dictionary
-
Everybody Wants the Same Thing — is the twelfth and final track on Scissor Sisters second album Ta Dah . Prior to the September 2006 release of Ta Dah , the song was performed at Live 8 in July 2005, at V Festival in August 2005 and at the EXIT Festival in July 2006. Everybody… … Wikipedia
-
amount to the same thing — to be nearly the same thing, after you consider it. She wanted him to suffer and she wanted to punish him, which amounts to the same thing … New idioms dictionary
-
come be the same thing — come to/be the same ˈthing idiom to have the same result or meaning Main entry: ↑thingidiom … Useful english dictionary
-
the same — 1》 identical; unchanged. → same the same the same thing as previously mentioned. → same … English new terms dictionary
-
(the) same to you! — may you do or have the same thing. → same … English new terms dictionary
-
harped on the same thing — talked persistently about the same issue, repeated himself over and over … English contemporary dictionary